2 JW beliefs that do not add up

ok so i know theres way more than just 2, but heres 2 that i could never figure out:

belief 1) jehovah is trying to prove his right to rule by allowing saturn a chance to do better/fail. This means extensive trauma for all humans as they suffer and die, basicly innocent vitums of this.

belief 2) In the paradise the bad memories of living in this saturns system will bewiped.

So i ask you: what is the point of belief number 1 if all those years of proving saturn wrong will no longer be remembered? how will gods name be vindicated if no one can remember how or why it was vindicated?????

comments?

Saturn?

Sylvia

Brilliant!  Why didn't I think of that all those years I was in?  I love sd-7's term for all this - theological swiss cheese! 

the devil  not the  planet

highdose of the cannot spell class

Spell checkers gone wild!  

Oh!  Satan!

That "proving Satan wrong" thing is totally hogwash.

The Almighty doesn't have to "prove" anything.

Sylvia

I'm with Sylvia - "what does God need with a starship?"

If it's that easy to deflect God's intentions, there should be easy ways to have him provide us all with millions of dollars to "prove" himself.

I was always suspicious of Saturn, but the really sinister one is Neptune.

Uh huh, no. You really need to watch out for Uranus! 

jehovah is trying to prove his right to rule by allowing saturn a chance to do better/fail.

Saturn failed...

GM tried to sell them off but couldn't find a buyer, so they're shutting down the brand.

So Jehovah has been vindicated and his sovereignty is intact.

Saturn did fail ... it was bought by General Motors.

Undercover, great minds think alike!

I remember being a little kid and wondering that. Why a God of love wants us to suffer to clear his name, it has never made any sense. 

And why would Jehovah drag us into His issues if He loved us?  Make us suffer because of his issues--and, as far as I see, it was Satan that was in the right for trying to free us from God's tyranny before He had a chance to develop it.  I would hate to see the kind of stagnant, blah world we would be in had they obeyed.

If the Watchtower Society was part of God's plan to clear his name then i'm thinking it clearly failed.

LD

People should worry less about Saturn and be more concerned about Uranus.