Disfellowshipped Over Celebrating Holidays?


Viewed 1102 times

    garbonzo posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 03:20:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 58 of 96
    Joined 5/28/2011

    I found this:

    Worldly celebrations such as Christmas - ks91-E p.95 (It appears celebrating birthdays is not a reason to be disfellowshipped

    ks91-E is the Pay Attention to Yourselves Elder's book, right? Well I can't find that on page 95 in that book! WTF?

    M steve2 posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 04:17:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 4424 of 8780
    Joined 10/31/2004

    Well, broadly speaking I think you're right in your assumption. However, one of my more fun-loving JW aunties was once disfellowshipped for getting kissed under the mistletoe. She never did clarify what part of the body that was and all the elders in the judicial room with her were even tighter-lipped.

    transhuman68 posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 04:34:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 1430 of 2368
    Joined 3/30/2010

    Yeah, nothing in the'secret books', lol.

    Maybe it should be km instead of ks?

    In the meantime, just hit the dubs with Romans 14:5

    mind blown posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 05:23:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 391 of 1534
    Joined 3/29/2010

    I do believe I read a post where a faded JW couple had Christmas decorations on their house, someone snitched them off and ened up in an elders meeting only to get DF'd.

    The elders will reason you're still a JW (since you didn't DA yourself) and will stumble an outsider, and or you do not believe the WTS is Gods orginization anymore. You can also be labeled an apostate for celebrating pagan holidays.

    You can't say you have doubts (that you kept to yourself) because you've already stated a position contrary to the WTS. They will expect you to repent or get DF'd.....that is of course if you get caught. I'm pretty sure of this.

    nugget posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 09:38:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 2761 of 3903
    Joined 11/22/2009

    Wordly celebrations such as.... is a catch all it doesn't list all celebrations so the elders can easily substitute any appropriate celebration into the gap including Birthdays. The bottom line is if you are not following the faith as taught by JWs you can be disfellowshipped. Part of their teachings is prohibition on Birthdays.

    Wizard of Oz posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 09:52:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 31 of 203
    Joined 2/19/2012

    Collosians Ch2v6-23 gives Dubs cause for thought as well. Especially v16

    outsmartthesystem posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 12:45:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 445 of 1178
    Joined 5/19/2011

    Mindblown is right. It isn't the act of celebrating a holiday that will get you DFd. It is the investigation they will launch BECAUSE of your celebration of a holiday that will do the trick. If they can find two people that you've talked to within the congregation that will admit that you told them you see nothing wrong with a particular holiday.......they can construe that to mean that you are rejecting the organization and creating a sect and trying to pull others away from the organization and follow in your footsteps. Or perhaps the elders may want to meet with you to give you some "encouragement" once they learn of your holiday decor. Their real intent will likely be to get you to say something incriminating. A simple "I think the governing body is wrong about holidays" = "I do not recognize their authority".

    Similar to the fact that AIDS doesn't kill a person......it just lowers the immune system so that another sickness can finish the person off. A celebration of a holiday will not get you DF'd necessarily....but the door to other accusations that it opens will finish you off.

    mP posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 13:22:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 410 of 4585
    Joined 2/21/2012

    are not jws having meetings on SUN day celebrating the holy sun ?

    NewChapter posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 13:28:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 6949 of 11807
    Joined 1/25/2011

    I think a poster here told me he had faded, and had a Christmas swag over a door and got df'd.

    Or maybe they are getting creative again, and they don't actually DF you, but YOU da by your actions. They are all about the word games for sure.


    Found Sheep posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 13:43:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 2774 of 3433
    Joined 5/13/2009

    well my lights are still up I guess I should take them down being spring and all

    WTWizard posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 14:20:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 12971 of 15092
    Joined 5/10/2007

    My lights are still up, despite that I know it is worshiping the sun. And that's where they are going to stay.

    I believe that anything can get you disfellowshipped, including eating something you enjoy for no good reason. All they need to do is bring in that "brazen conduct", and you get it for brazen conduct regardless of whether the holiday or other activity was itself objectionable.

    M leavingwt posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 14:25:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 13956 of 14200
    Joined 6/16/2008

    You can be disfellowshipped for anything that three elders agree upon. Further, the Society can invent a new reason to disfellowship you and do so retroactively.

    The game is rigged.

    RayPublisher posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 17:08:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 400 of 1918
    Joined 3/1/2011

    There's a great blog by a former JW and his wife- they got DFed for celebrating their son's birthday and posting the pics on facebook.

    Disillusioned Lost-Lamb posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 17:47:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 304 of 1159
    Joined 2/3/2012

    WTWizard, my thoughts exactly.

    If they can't find something wrong, they'll make it up and then use the catchall brazen conduct.

    Disillusioned Lost-Lamb posted Thu, 22 Mar 2012 17:50:00 GMT(3/22/2012)

    Post 305 of 1159
    Joined 2/3/2012

    By the way I've gotten searing sneering glares and finger waggles just for buying marked down items the day after a holiday.

    And the items were not "holiday" in any way, I'm talking things like cheap plain table clothes after thanksgiving.


      Confirm ...