Is Smoking the practice of Spiritism?


Viewed 1979 times

    M freedomfighter posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 00:36:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 1 of 133
    Joined 11/21/2007

    Hi guys,

    I was raised as a JW and was baptised when i was 16. I am now 35 and have finally realised that "The Truth" is actually the opposite.

    My family has a long history of mental illness and i am "Lucky" to only suffer Deppression and Panic Attacks.I believe what i was taught as Truth has effected me adversely. E.g " You won't have to go to school son, Armageddon will be here before then." "You won't have to worry about getting a job son,this system is nearly over" etc. The Result? I was never ready for anything!

    Anyway my sister was DF twice when i was growing up and my older brother is also. My sister is back in but is unhappy ( Trying to please Mum and Dad). I have seen and experienced many unchristian behaviours. I cannot accept that when you go to the elders for help and when they decide to disfellowship you - everybody you have known and been friends with treat you like some kind of Murderer. Would Jesus treat anyone like this?

    Anyway i started smoking because i became very depressed. I called the Elders and they treated me real nice.Then they showed me a Watchtower that directly related smoking to "The practice of Spiritism".( I strongly disagree). I was DF, which is what i wanted. You cannot leave the Witnesses on good terms. As the meeting came to an end the Presiding Overseer said " Just because you are now out doesn't give you licence to do what you like" ( I thought "They're still trying to control me even when I'm out, NO ONE has that right.) I said " Yes I know we are all accountable to Jehovah in the end". So that was that and i have been shunned ever since.

    I have done thorough research into the witnesses and by taking a step back i can see that this organisation has become part of what they were preaching against 100 yrs ago "Religion is a Snare and a Racket". They have alot to answer for.

    Sincerely Jason

    M PEC posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 00:49:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 1466 of 2554
    Joined 1/19/2007

    freedomfighter, welcome to JWD.

    I agree with you 100%, the WTS has become what they accused all other religions of being.


    Robert222 posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 00:56:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 90 of 146
    Joined 4/22/2006

    I also agree 100%. It took me a very long time to walk away but I do not regret it. My family latched onto the "truth" yrs ago and they also have mental illness. Mom was afraid to go outside, my father was a pathological liar, my grandfather committed suicide. And yeah, I was never to graduate high school.

    Satanus posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 01:00:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 12235 of 20962
    Joined 8/31/2001

    Glad you got free. As a jw, i used to wonder how, exactly, smoking was spiritism. I didn't recieve any good answers. In my research, i found that smokers were slightly more liberal, and ready to try new things. But, that attitude could have been a precondition in smokers.


    Leolaia posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 01:06:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 10416 of 16188
    Joined 9/1/2002

    I think the Society bases this claim on the fact that "spiritism" in the NT translates the Greek word pharmakia "drugs". Unbelievable, isn't it? Taking an aspirin should be considered spiritism on the same basis.

    M Gopher posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 01:13:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 7995 of 10931
    Joined 3/18/2001


    Welcome to the forum! And smoking, unhealthy though it is, is not spiritism. Unless you regularly perform spiritistic practices when smoking (LOL).

    Speaking of controlling:

    You know they have rules about DF'd persons talking to other DF'd persons. Weird. So what's a DF'd person to do, seeing that they're not supposed to talk to JW"s, other DF'd ones, and all worldly people (who are bad associates)? They'd have you sitting alone in your own house. What control freaks!

    M abyss57 posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 01:47:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 2 of 10
    Joined 10/6/2007

    Congratulations! You immediately realized they are control freaks...and hypocrites!! Do you know how many witnesses "in good standing" smoke?? You would be suprised...or maybe not, anymore. I know an elder in excellent standing in the district and circuit around here that still uses "pot" !! I had to kick 4 Bethelites out of my room at Bethel when they decided to have their cigar tasting party in my room at the Towers. I didn't object to their smoking...I just didn't need the extra "attention" to my room at that time...Usually they went to the 'Steak and Brew" downtown for their cigar will feel better and mentally healthier every day that you're away from them...

    Relax...breath deep...keep them out of your life and out of your MIND...Welcome!

    VoidEater posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 02:13:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 186 of 3065
    Joined 10/30/2007

    Welcome, Jason! No, smoking is not spiritism, unless you are making some mighty strange definitions of spiritism. The WBTS equates smoking to using might altering drugs, which they say opens the door to evil spirits entering your mind. Wonder why "Gesundheit" is so wrong...

    M marmot posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 03:00:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 282 of 625
    Joined 9/14/2007

    Actually, gesundheit is fine but "bless you" isn't according to the talmud...I mean the witnesses. Gesundheit is just German for "good health to you" (roughly translated, as per my German teacher in college) As for smoking, they equate it with spiritism because tobacco leaves were once used in religious ceremonies and the nicotine has a bit of an effect on the nervous system. Bunch of baloney if you ask me, because coffee has WAY more of an effect yet it's a-ok. Dancing is also used to enter trance-states in shamanism, yet dancing is okay too - just so long as you're not doing one of those demonic dances like the twist (look this one up on your watchtower CD library for some hilarity). I tell ya, those witnesses see the Devil around every corner.

    choosing life posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 03:27:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 1353 of 2498
    Joined 4/15/2006

    Welcome freedomfighter,

    Sounds like you have had a lot of experience with the dark side of jws. Shunning your own flesh and blood is evil and smoking cigarettes has nothing to do with spiritism. It's not the best for your health, but neither is obesity and that never stopped a jw from overeating.

    M spiritboi posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 04:09:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 65 of 92
    Joined 10/28/2007

    Freedom, a warm welcome for you!

    I found out some new things about the borg from your post :

    when you go to the elders for help and when they decide to disfellowship you

    what??? A person must be sorry for wat he has done and decided to seek help from the elders
    and they DF'ed him???

    " Just because you are now out doesn't give you licence to do what you like"

    We are already out. Why do they want to bother whether we place our cock pointing up or pointing

    Now on spiritism and smoking...

    I practice spiritism and oso smoke.

    Many of my smokers friends do not practising spiritism.

    My dad has been practicing spiritism for the past 20-30 yrs. But he does not smoke!

    Anybody has that awake article on smoking and spiritism? Can scan and pm it to me??????

    ******************************* R.I.D.I.C.U.L.O.U.S *************************************

    F Barbie Doll posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 04:19:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 212 of 1696
    Joined 7/30/2007


    onacruse posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 04:37:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 8026 of 6692
    Joined 7/3/2002

    If you desire more definitive information, I'd be glad to oblige.

    R.Crusoe posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 04:43:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 335 of 2596
    Joined 3/29/2007

    That many things are put down to one bad thing or another in the WTBTS that it piles burdens upon your shoulders greater than you can bear. So my advice is work it out for yourself as to whether God is bothered when another million humans will die in the next week of all sorts of premature disease etc. Have yourself a smoke and go help somebody so you can offset your sin-footprint!

    M JK666 posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 04:50:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 1496 of 3833
    Joined 8/27/2004


    Welcome to JWD!

    As an act of rebellion after being DF'ed, I began smoking. Now I refer to it as my "garlic necklace." I use it as an excuse for not going back to the religion, when my family leans on me to do so. My worldly girlfriend worked better though, when we broke up a month ago, they started in again.

    I will quit one day, but not today!


    Hortensia posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 06:15:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 2296 of 7616
    Joined 12/9/2006

    smoking is NOT good for you. That said, I found it quite interesting to learn years ago, when I was living with a bipolar man, that one of the few sources of lithium in food sources is tobacco leaves. Now, I found this out in a government publication on nutrients and I thought it was really interesting that tobacco was considered a "food." But I also found it interesting that whenever my friend got really down he would go buy a couple of cigars and smoke them and feel better. So maybe for a really depressed person the cigarette is not only addictive but is also a form of self-medicating, a little lithium to even things out.

    onacruse posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 06:28:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 8030 of 6692
    Joined 7/3/2002

    Hortensia, one of the things I've learned about nicotine is that it's a serotonin 'manipulator' in the same class with dietary carbohydrates (including alcohol) and stimulants (including caffeine) and all the other neurotransmitter modifiers that we regularly consume in one way or another. The interplay between the pancreas, liver, thyroid, BMI, mitochondrial glucose absorbtion level, etc., is such that the brain is simply looking for an "equilibrium" between the extremes.

    Every one of the substances which we consume to achieve that equilibrium has its own disadvantages., including nicotine.

    I didn't know about the lithium aspect. Interesting.

    Hortensia posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 06:29:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 2297 of 7616
    Joined 12/9/2006

    Thanks for the info - I didn't know - very interesting!

    M justhuman posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 09:10:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 960 of 1542
    Joined 8/18/2001

    well I don't like smoking is such an awfull habit

    M monophonic posted Thu, 22 Nov 2007 11:34:00 GMT(11/22/2007)

    Post 507 of 771
    Joined 5/25/2007

    freedomfighter, welcome.

    i too suffer from anxiety and panic attacks, mostly related to growing up a jw. baptized at 16 as well.

    as said by other replies, if smoking is drugs and drugs is spiritism, then anti-depressants are also spiritism. it's a joke. the wtbts applies what's convenient without even considering the big picture.


      Confirm ...